Stanley Kubrick’s Paths of Glory

Stanley Kubrick’s Paths of Glory (1957) was his first full-length feature devoted to war, a subject that he would revisit several times throughout his career. Today, his later film Full Metal Jacket (1987) is generally held in higher regard, or at least is more widely remembered. Paths of Glory, however, is one of Kubrick’s greatest works in my eyes.

The central theme running through Kubrick’s work is the struggle of man to maintain his individuality and control over his life in the face of larger forces. Perhaps this is seen no more clearly than in the military, and explains why Kubrick revisited the subject of war so frequently.

The film tells the tale of Colonel Dax, played by Kirk Douglas, a member of the French military during WWI. In order to advance his reputation and earn another medal, General Mireau, played by George Macready, orders a suicidal attack on a German encampment known as the “anthill.” While talking to Dax, Mireau reveals that he expects the attack to cost approximately 65% of Dax’s troops. Dax is hesitant, but goes through with the order. However, he is quickly required to retreat.

The lives of the soldiers of Dax’s regiment are tossed away by Mireau in order to gain himself recognition. He is fully aware it is a suicide mission. When the soldiers retreat to their trench, Mireau orders another unit to open fire on them in order to get them to move. The other unit refuses, and Mireau has several of the members of Dax’s regiment put up on charges of cowardice. During the trial, they have very little say, instead having to rely on Dax to protect them, a task in which he is ultimately unsuccessful.

The acting in the film is excellent. As is always the case with Kubrick, the editing, cinematography, and music are exceptional. The early tracking shots through the trenches are among Kubrick’s best. The Criterion Collection recently released the film on DVD. Perhaps this re-release will allow the film to finally rise and attain the widespread recognition that it deserves.

John Ford’s Drums Along the Mohawk

John Ford stands atop a pedestal as America’s cinematic poet laureate – the man who was able to tap into the heart and soul of America and reveal it through his works. His 1939 film Drums Along the Mohawk depicts events during the Revolutionary War, illustrating the American’s desperate fight for freedom. Starring Ford regular Henry Fonda and Claudette Colbert, the film tells the tale of Gilbert Martin and his wife Lana who return to Martin’s cabin in upstate New York, only to be displaced by the Native Americans who have teamed with the British to crush the American rebellion.

The film, as is the case with the majority of Ford’s works, is controversial for its blatant, over-the-top racism, most notably towards Native Americans, and its misogynistic portrayal of women. While racism and sexism were prevalent in early films, these issues are so problematic in Ford’s works because of the promise of freedom and equality offered by them. Early on, Martin claims during a meeting that they shouldn’t have any problems from the Native Americans, having always treated them as equals. Anyone with a vague knowledge of American history knows that this is almost surely not true. There does exist one “civilized,” Christian Native American; however, he mostly serves as comic relief, destroying any honorable reasoning for his existence.

One of the most offensive images in the film is also one of the last. After defeating the British, the Americans raise the newly-stitched American flag. The standard is looked on with pride and admiration by the Americans, including a black woman, who is almost surely a slave. While we are meant to admire the promises of the flag, we are contradictorily disgusted by the hypocrisies that single shot reveal, upstaging the entire film. It also occurs at the very end, sticking with the viewer as they leave.

These problems are unfortunate, because apart from them, the film is rather good. Fonda is excellent, as always, and Colbert does a good job as the shrieking, hysterical wife. Politics aside, the film stands to show why Ford is such an enduring figure.